Review by Jim Wert
DragonCon High Fantasy
Tolkien Enthusiast
@MadeyeGamgee

Still pondering my reflections on the Tolkien movie.

My bottom line is this is a worthy effort worth any Tolkien fan investing in a ticket to go see. Yes, it’s fictionalized, yes there are portrayals which will bother some of us more inclined toward historical accuracy, yes there are structural issues with the film that will risk pulling a new- or non-Tolkien fan out of the thread and momentum of the film. But there are beautiful moments and themes, and it’s wonderful to see this part of Tolkien’s life — one that many have very little exposure to — portrayed with loving respect on the big screen. And while I don’t agree with all of his choices, the director, Dome Karukoski, is a clear and well-studied fan. It’s his labor of love, even if all don’t love that labor. Respect.

Want full access?

Exclusive content (on this page AND the entire site) is available to members only. But that can be you!

Members receive access to all our resources!

Already a member?
Login Here.

Recent content

Delving into Tolkien’s Dark Sides (Part 1)

Delving into Tolkien’s Dark Sides (Part 1)

Fall season has arrived in my Shire. Along with the splash of my favorite leaf colors—burnt orange, apple red, and golden yellow—there’s a crisp chill in the air. Most mornings and evenings now call for a sweatshirt while walking my fine canine, Musti the Hound.…

read more
Interview with David Rowe

Interview with David Rowe

With whom would David choose to enjoy elevensies? Join John Pletcher for a the answer and more discussion with David Rowe, author of The Proverbs of Middle Earth. An Arabic proverb says, “Before you shoot the arrow of truth, dip it in honey.” This book is…

read more
Interview with K. B. Hoyle

Interview with K. B. Hoyle

Join Eucatastrophe co-founder Dan Cruver for a discussion with K. B. Hoyle, multiple award-winning Young Adult author, a public speaker, and a creative writing instructor. Her love and respect for Tolkien is evident as she discusses the influence of his writings on her life and career.…

read more