Review by Jim Wert
DragonCon High Fantasy
Tolkien Enthusiast
@MadeyeGamgee

Still pondering my reflections on the Tolkien movie.

My bottom line is this is a worthy effort worth any Tolkien fan investing in a ticket to go see. Yes, it’s fictionalized, yes there are portrayals which will bother some of us more inclined toward historical accuracy, yes there are structural issues with the film that will risk pulling a new- or non-Tolkien fan out of the thread and momentum of the film. But there are beautiful moments and themes, and it’s wonderful to see this part of Tolkien’s life — one that many have very little exposure to — portrayed with loving respect on the big screen. And while I don’t agree with all of his choices, the director, Dome Karukoski, is a clear and well-studied fan. It’s his labor of love, even if all don’t love that labor. Respect.

Want to read the rest?

Unlock this content (and the entire rest of the site) with a free. no-obligation 30-day trial.

Recent content

For the Love of Middle-earth Music

For the Love of Middle-earth Music

Eurielle From an idyllic, leafy Yorkshire upbringing and a lifetime dedicated to classical training comes Eurielle. To date, Eurielle has built up a substantial catalogue of releases which have attracted a large fan base online, with millions of views and streams of her recordings and videos on both YouTube and Spotify. Her work has already…

read more
Many Wonderful Waters to Behold

Many Wonderful Waters to Behold

It is difficult to say what the most captivating water scene is in the Legendarium. Is it Kheled-zâram, Mirrormere? Despite any hurt or weariness, it draws you by its still blue water—only to transform before your very eyes whence you see the forms of the encircling mountains mirrored in a profound blue. The peaks are…

read more
Called to the Sea

Called to the Sea

“And at that hour the sun went down beyond the rim of the world, as a mighty fire; and Tuor stood alone upon the cliff with outspread arms, and a great yearning filled his heart.” The image of Tuor looking upon the Belegaer for the first time never fails to inspire me in its symbolism…

read more

Unlock immediate site-wide access with a free, no-obligation 30-Day trial.

Unlock immediate access with a free, no-obligation 30-Day trial.